war?,Two weeks into the latest bout of blood and ruin in the Middle East,
a question still reverberates from Jerusalem to Beirut and beyond: Why?
Why did Hezbollah's guerrillas provoke an Israel already under pressure
elsewhere? Why did Israel hit back a thousand-fold, risking condemnation
and untold consequences?
Veteran observers see miscalculation, hidden motives, a military
blunder.,Chinadaily,Chinadaily.com.cn' >Why did Mideast descend again
into war?
WORLD / Background
Why did Mideast descend again into war?
(AP)
Updated: 2006-07-28 08:43
NEW YORK - Two weeks into the latest bout of blood and ruin in the Middle
East, a question still reverberates from Jerusalem to Beirut and beyond:
Why? Why did Hezbollah's guerrillas provoke an Israel already under
pressure elsewhere? Why did Israel hit back a thousand-fold, risking
condemnation and untold consequences?
Veteran observers see miscalculation, hidden motives, a military blunder.
Hezbollah itself says it did not expect the furious backlash of Israeli
bombs and artillery barrages that have battered Lebanon since July 12,
when the Islamic group's militiamen killed three Israeli soldiers and
seized two others in a cross-border raid.
"Hezbollah miscalculated," said political scientist Farid Khazen, a
Christian member of Lebanon's parliament. They expected pinprick return
fire, and then backroom dealing to swap three Lebanese prisoners for the
Israelis, he said.
"But they misread the changing international and regional situation -
September 11, the Iraq war, the fact Israel had a kidnapped soldier in
Gaza. Now with two in Hezbollah's hands, that's a recipe for Israel to go
completely wild."
Events in Lebanon, meanwhile, had supplied the ingredients for
Hezbollah's bold action.
In "national dialogue" sessions that began last March, talks among
Beirut's sectarian and political factions had focused on Hezbollah,
building pressure on this last armed Lebanese militia to disarm, as
called for in a U.N. resolution.
The Shiite cadres needed to revive their cause, said Edward S. Walker
Jr., a veteran U.S. Mideast diplomat.
"Hezbollah had been losing ground in southern Lebanon because its real
claim to fame was in standing up to Israel" until 2000, when Israeli
occupation troops withdrew from Lebanon's south, said Walker, president
of the Middle East Institute in Washington.
"Now there was no Israel to stand up to anymore."
But there were still the prisoners. Analysts believe Hezbollah wanted to
link a Lebanese-Israeli exchange with a swap of Palestinian detainees for
the soldier seized June 25 on the southern Israeli border by Gaza's Hamas
fighters.
"Hezbollah acted out of solidarity with Hamas, to pre-empt Hamas, to get
a grip on prisoner exchanges and establish itself in a prominent role,"
said Israeli analyst Yossi Alpher, an ex-intelligence official.
Some speculate Hezbollah's July 12 raid into northernmost Israel may even
have been timed to scuttle an imminent Palestinians-only deal mediated by
Egypt.
The sudden "second shoe" on the northern border proved too much for the
Israelis, said Daniel C. Kurtzer, U.S. ambassador to Israel in 2001-2005.
"If not for the Gaza situation, they might have responded in a more
traditional tit-for-tat way - bloody noses and then ending up trading
prisoners," Kurtzer said.
Instead, Israel responded with devastating air and artillery attacks on
Lebanon, extending beyond Hezbollah military targets in what analysts see
as an effort to pressure other Lebanese parties into neutralizing
Hezbollah.
"I think the Israelis reacted as they did because they felt for the first
time in Gaza, and again in south Lebanon, they are vulnerable, their
invincibility was for the first time compromised," said Jordanian
commentator Hasan Abu Nimah.
They are vulnerable, in particular, to the missiles Hezbollah has fired
back, longer-range than ever before.
The Israeli retaliation was "disproportionate to the incident, but
proportionate to the threat," said Alpher.
Could things have been different? Perhaps, said Kurtzer - if Israel's
military had not blundered.
The Gaza kidnapping has already been officially blamed on an Israeli
"operational failure." In the north, Hezbollah long boasted it would grab
Israeli soldiers. It tried and failed last November.
"I left as ambassador last September, and for at least six months before
that Hezbollah was trying to do what it did recently," Kurtzer said. "The
Israelis have to analyze how they failed so miserably, allowing it to
happen knowing they were trying to do it."
Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours
Today's Top News
� Satellite to help predict earthquakes
� UN expresses shock at Israeli bombing
� Farmers to be better compensated
� Kaemi kills at least 25; 53 missing
� China to be No. 3 US export market
Top World News
� U.S. may send 5,000 more troops to Baghdad
� Israel decides not to expand offensive
� UN fails to agree statement on observer deaths
� India cautiously oks US nuke deal
� Iraqi PM calls for more money and troops
Alibaba is the largest B2B marketplace in the world. Source model ship,
wooden puzzle, one-piece toilet, RC hovercraft, photo album, prom dress,
pocket bike, Vaginal Speculum, Samurai Sword, String Panty and PVC Pipe.
Learn Chinese, Learning Chinese, Learning Materials, Mandarin audio lessons, Chinese writing lessons, Chinese vocabulary lists, About chinese characters, News in Chinese, Go to China, Travel to China, Study in China, Teach in China, Dictionaries, Learn Chinese Painting, Your name in Chinese, Chinese calligraphy, Chinese songs, Chinese proverbs, Chinese poetry, Chinese tattoo, Beijing 2008 Olympics, Mandarin Phrasebook, Chinese editor, Pinyin editor, China Travel, Travel to Beijing, Travel to Tibet
No comments:
Post a Comment